RIVERHEAD, NY — A former Long Island high school teacher and soccer coach was sentenced Wednesday to three years in state prison after pleading guilty to posing as a teenage boy online to solicit nude images from underage girls and sending them explicit photos of himself.
Ryan McCaffery, 38, of Ridge, New York, had worked as a social studies teacher and junior varsity boys soccer coach at Riverhead High School in Suffolk County before his crimes came to light. He pleaded guilty in September to two counts of first-degree disseminating indecent material to minors as a sexually motivated felony and one count of endangering the welfare of a child. The sentencing, handed down Oct. 21 by Acting Supreme Court Justice Karen M. Wilutis at the Arthur Cromarty Court Complex in Riverhead, closes the New York chapter of a case that also produced a separate conviction in New Jersey.
The investigation began Nov. 4, 2024, when the New York State Police Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force received a tip from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. The tip indicated that an individual had shared child sexual abuse material on Kik, a messaging application. Task force investigators traced the activity and, on Jan. 17, 2025, executed a search warrant at McCaffery’s home in Ridge, seizing several electronic devices. A digital forensic analysis of those devices showed that between December 2024 and January 2025, McCaffery had created a Snapchat account under the name “c_chambers77” and presented himself as a teenage boy. He used Snapchat’s “quick add” feature to contact hundreds of random accounts, targeting underage girls, sending photos of his exposed genitals and requesting nude images in return, according to Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney. Investigators also found that McCaffery had attempted to view and purchase additional child sexual abuse images and videos, and had shared at least one such video with another user on Kik.
During the sentencing, Justice Wilutis told McCaffery she would honor the agreed-upon sentence negotiated by prosecutors but made clear she viewed it as insufficient. “You’ve been given a gift, Mr. McCaffery,” the judge said. “I hope you realize that.” She added that as a teacher, McCaffery had held a position of trust “akin to a guardian of children or a surrogate parent,” and that the sentence “quite frankly is not enough.” McCaffery and his attorney, Elena Fast of Manhattan, declined to address the judge during the proceeding. The victims were not present and made no statement. McCaffery appeared in court wearing a green Suffolk County Correctional Facility jumpsuit. Following his three-year prison term, he will serve five years of post-release supervision, prosecutors said.
McCaffery resigned from Riverhead High School on Feb. 5, 2025. School officials said at the time that he cited personal reasons for leaving. His departure came shortly after he turned himself in to the Bergen County Prosecutor’s Office in New Jersey on Feb. 14, 2025, on charges stemming from similar conduct. Then-Interim Superintendent Cheryl Pedisich sent a letter to Riverhead families stating that the New Jersey charges were not related to McCaffery’s work in the district or any interactions with Riverhead students. The district placed him on unpaid leave and said it was cooperating with law enforcement. State police in New York arrested McCaffery on May 12, 2025, following the conclusion of their investigation, and he was subsequently indicted in Suffolk County on child sexual performance and related charges. Court records show McCaffery also pleaded guilty in Bergen County, New Jersey, and received a five-year sentence there that began Feb. 11, 2026. The New York and New Jersey sentences will run concurrently.
McCaffery entered his guilty plea on Sept. 21, 2026, before Justice Wilutis. The two New York felony counts each qualify as class D felonies under state law, and the child endangerment count is a class A misdemeanor. The district attorney’s office did not release details of the specific New Jersey sentence beyond confirming a conviction had been entered in Bergen County. Fast, McCaffery’s defense attorney, could not immediately be reached for comment following the sentencing. The Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office confirmed McCaffery will be required to register as a sex offender and serve the five-year post-release supervision term in addition to his prison time, though the office did not specify his registration level in Wednesday’s announcement.
District Attorney Tierney issued a statement after the sentencing that addressed the broader responsibility adults hold toward children. “Adults have a responsibility to protect children, not expose them to sexually explicit material,” Tierney said. “The defendant’s conduct was deeply disturbing and wholly unacceptable. Children should never have to navigate this kind of exploitation or have their innocence stolen by an adult’s actions. This sentence holds the defendant accountable for conduct that has no place in our community.” Riverhead school officials had previously described McCaffery as a teacher whose classroom conduct had not been the subject of complaints. Pedisich’s 2025 letter told families: “We find deplorable the actions and behavior Mr. McCaffrey is accused of, and will be cooperating with law enforcement in any ongoing investigations.” The district said the safety of students remained its highest priority.
McCaffery is scheduled to begin serving his New York sentence. He had already been held at the Suffolk County Correctional Facility ahead of the Oct. 21 proceeding. The Bergen County sentence started Feb. 11, 2026, meaning the concurrent New York term will run alongside whatever time remains on the New Jersey term.

