BOSTON, MA — A Suffolk County jury on Friday awarded former MIT biology professor David Sabatini, 58, $6 million in damages after finding that fellow scientist Kristin Knouse, 38, defamed him and interfered with his ability to earn a living following a dispute over their sexual relationship.
The verdict closed a five-year legal battle that cost Sabatini two prestigious positions, derailed what colleagues described as a Nobel Prize-caliber research career, and pushed him to attempt suicide. The jury of seven women and six men rejected every one of Knouse’s counterclaims, including her allegation that Sabatini coerced her into a sexual relationship and fostered a hostile workplace at the Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Knouse’s attorney said her client will appeal. The outcome drew immediate calls from prominent backers for MIT and the Whitehead Institute to publicly account for how they handled the case in 2021.
Sabatini had spent nearly 24 years leading a research lab at the Whitehead Institute, an independent nonprofit affiliated with MIT. His work on mTOR, a protein that regulates cell growth, produced insights into aging, cancer, diabetes, and neurodegenerative diseases and generated serious discussion in the scientific community about a potential Nobel Prize. He and Knouse first met in 2012, when she was a graduate student at Harvard and MIT and he sat on her dissertation committee. In 2018, after Knouse joined Whitehead as a fellow, the two began a sexual relationship. Both scientists have acknowledged having sex at a conference in Washington, D.C., that year, though they disagreed sharply about whether it was consensual. Sabatini’s attorneys presented text messages Knouse sent the morning after that encounter in which she expressed no regrets, according to the Boston Globe. The relationship continued for roughly a year and a half, with the two scientists telling investigators they had sex approximately 15 times while also maintaining what Sabatini described as a close friendship. He said he mentored her throughout and helped her set up her own laboratory.
The relationship ended in January 2020 when Sabatini told Knouse he wanted to date another woman. Within weeks, Knouse began telling colleagues at Whitehead and MIT that Sabatini had sexually harassed her, according to court documents. In October 2020, she formally reported the alleged harassment to Whitehead leadership. The institute hired the law firm Hinckley, Allen and Snyder to conduct an independent investigation. Separately, a routine diversity survey of Whitehead employees had surfaced concerns about Sabatini’s lab culture. The law firm interviewed Knouse and other members of the Whitehead community, and in August 2021 issued a report finding that Sabatini had engaged in and tolerated “sexist and sexualized work discussions” and that such conduct was described as an implicit part of succeeding in his laboratory. The report also cited a “culture of fear and retaliation.” On August 20, 2021, Sabatini resigned after learning that Whitehead was preparing to terminate him. His co-employer, the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, had already fired him. MIT placed him on administrative leave and later, after its own review committee recommended revoking his tenure, Sabatini formally resigned from his tenured faculty position in 2022.
Sabatini filed a civil lawsuit against Knouse, the Whitehead Institute, and institute director Ruth Lehmann, alleging defamation and tortious interference with his professional relationships. The claims against Whitehead were later dismissed by the court, leaving Sabatini and Knouse as the sole remaining parties. Knouse filed a counterclaim alleging that Sabatini abused his position of power over her. During the three-week trial in Suffolk Superior Court, Sabatini’s legal team presented evidence they said demonstrated not only that the relationship was consensual, but that Knouse had grown jealous after learning Sabatini was interested in another woman and sought to have him fired. One text message exchange from 2020 showed Knouse writing that she was “pouring a lot of energy and emotion into a game I’m destined to lose,” and in the same exchange saying she wanted “to do everything and anything I can to help you.” Sabatini told Fox News Digital after the verdict that the outcome felt like “a complete sweep,” adding, “We had won everything, lost nothing.” He also said he was unprepared for the moment the foreperson read each of Knouse’s counts aloud and each one was dismissed. “I don’t know if I still believe it, to be honest with you,” he told the Boston Globe in a phone interview the Sunday after the verdict.
The personal toll on Sabatini was severe. He described slipping into depression after being removed from his positions, and he testified in court that he attempted suicide. Shortly after news broke that New York University’s Grossman School of Medicine was considering hiring him in 2022, approximately 200 graduate students, faculty, and alumni staged a walkout to protest the potential appointment, and NYU ultimately did not offer him a job. Protesters also appeared outside his parents’ home. His parents, nephew, and teenage son began receiving threats after Knouse’s allegations became public. “Everyone who came out and tried to defend me got attacked every which way,” Sabatini told Fox News Digital. In 2023, hedge fund billionaire Bill Ackman and an anonymous donor pledged $25 million over five years to support Sabatini’s return to science. Sabatini accepted a position at the Institute of Organic Chemistry and Biochemistry in Prague, later opening a Boston-area branch of the institute. He said finding foreign employment was “a necessity” because there were no options left for him in the United States. Ackman, a vocal critic of MIT’s institutional leadership, posted on social media following the verdict calling on the university to fire Lehmann and reinstate Sabatini’s tenure. “Bill saved my life,” Sabatini said, while denying reports that Ackman helped fund his legal defense.
The scene in the courtroom after the verdict was tense. Knouse and members of her legal team remained in the empty courtroom for some time, crying and holding one another. Sabatini’s attorney, Lisa Arrowood, said a longtime member of Knouse’s lab who had testified on her behalf became visibly angry and physically “body checked” a member of Arrowood’s legal team. “I’ve been doing this for 44 years and I’ve never seen anyone react like this,” Arrowood told the Globe. Knouse’s attorney, Ellen Zucker, flatly denied the account. “That is completely ludicrous,” Zucker said, telling the Globe that Knouse’s supporters were simply standing with her and that no one struck anyone. Zucker said she and her client do not regret pursuing the case. “Multiple women came into court to speak about David Sabatini’s conduct towards them,” Zucker said. “Kristin Knouse testified truthfully about hers.” Zucker framed the verdict as reflecting a broader cultural failure to hold powerful men accountable, comparing it to the response to sexual assault allegations made at Cornell University. Arrowood, for her part, called the verdict a full restoration. “We are so happy that we got David Sabatini’s good name back,” she said. “Now he can be regarded as the brilliant scientist he is.”
MIT spokeswoman Kimberly Allen issued a statement noting that the Whitehead Institute is an independent nonprofit with its own leadership and that MIT was not a party to the lawsuit. The Whitehead Institute’s board of directors said it has “full confidence” in Lehmann and in the workplace policies under which the 2021 investigation was conducted, noting that all of Sabatini’s claims against the institute were previously dismissed by the court. Jeffrey Flier, former dean of Harvard Medical School, posted on social media questioning what the jury’s findings imply about the validity of MIT’s original response and said he had “significant prior concerns about due process of the investigation.” Sabatini told the Globe he wants greater “accountability in how these decisions are made, more transparency” from both institutions. Knouse is currently an assistant professor of biology at MIT and a faculty member of its Koch Institute for Integrative Cancer Research. It remains unclear how she will satisfy the $6 million judgment plus interest. Zucker confirmed that Knouse plans to appeal, and Sabatini’s legal team said it also intends to challenge the earlier dismissal of his claims against the Whitehead Institute.
Sabatini said his first priority is spending time with his teenage son before the boy leaves for college, and he expressed a desire to eventually return to working primarily in the United States. He told the New York Times he hopes the verdict begins the process of rebuilding his reputation. “Before I was judged for having a great lab and for providing great mentoring,” he said. “I hope that I can get back to being judged by my science and my training.” The next step in the case will be the formal filing of Knouse’s appeal, with Sabatini’s attorneys also expected to file their challenge to the Whitehead claims dismissal.

