STARKE, FL — A Florida prisoner who admitted to killing his sleeping cellmate in 2008 specifically to earn a death sentence is scheduled to be executed Tuesday by lethal injection at Florida State Prison, nearly 18 years after the unprovoked attack.
James Robertson, 63, pleaded guilty to first-degree murder in the strangling of fellow inmate Frank Hart and has since waived every legal avenue available to challenge his conviction or sentence. His case has drawn fresh attention to questions about whether the death penalty itself can, in rare circumstances, motivate violence rather than deter it. Robertson’s scheduled execution is also unfolding as Florida leads the nation in executions for the second consecutive year, accounting for more than half of all executions carried out across the United States so far in 2026.
According to court records, Robertson was incarcerated at Charlotte Correctional Institution, north of Fort Myers, in December 2008 when he fashioned a makeshift ligature from several socks tied together and used it to strangle Hart while Hart slept. Investigators said Robertson told them the attack was entirely unprovoked and that he carried it out with a single goal: to be sentenced to death rather than spend the remainder of his life in prison. Robertson pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and waived the penalty phase of his trial, which would have allowed a jury to recommend either death or life in prison. A judge sentenced him to death. Robertson later abandoned all post-conviction proceedings. During a court hearing earlier this month, he again told a judge that he understood his execution had been scheduled and that he did not want to pursue any final appeals before either the Florida Supreme Court or the U.S. Supreme Court. Robertson is set to receive a three-drug lethal injection beginning at noon at Florida State Prison near Starke.
Robertson has a lengthy criminal history that predates the 2008 killing by nearly three decades. He first entered prison in 1980 at age 17, following convictions for assault and burglary. Over the following years, his sentence grew substantially as he accumulated additional convictions for offenses committed behind bars, including possessing weapons, battery and attempted escapes. Hart, his victim, had been imprisoned in 2003 following a sexual battery conviction. Robertson’s execution was originally planned as one of two scheduled for the same day. However, Gov. Ron DeSantis withdrew a death warrant last week for a second inmate, William Lee Thompson, 74, without providing a public explanation. The withdrawal followed an earlier stay that had been granted to allow Thompson to undergo a psychiatric evaluation. Records indicate it is the first time DeSantis has withdrawn a death warrant. Thompson remains on death row and could face a new death warrant in the future. His attorneys have said he suffers from dementia and that his health is deteriorating, and they have called for him to be transferred to an adequate medical facility.
Florida’s pace of executions under DeSantis has been historically aggressive. The governor oversaw 19 executions in 2025, more than any Florida governor in a single year since capital punishment was reinstated in the state in 1976. Robertson would become the 17th person executed in Florida in 2026. Of the 30 executions carried out nationwide so far this year, more than half have taken place in Florida. In July, the state carried out a double execution — the first in the country in nearly a decade. Two additional executions are already scheduled: William Reaves, 77, on Oct. 20, and Jesse Guardado, 64, on Nov. 5. Reaves was convicted of fatally shooting a sheriff’s deputy in 1986. Guardado was convicted of robbing and killing a woman in 2004 to obtain money for drugs. A total of 47 executions were carried out across the United States in 2025. If Robertson, Reaves and Guardado are all executed as planned, Florida will match its 2025 single-year record before the end of 2026, with eight weeks still remaining in the year.
Thompson’s case adds another layer of complexity to Florida’s death row landscape. He is the third Florida governor to sign a death warrant for Thompson, joining former governors Bob Graham and Bob Martinez, both of whom scheduled executions for Thompson in the 1980s. Legal challenges and court-ordered stays prevented those executions from being carried out when Florida still used the electric chair. DeSantis, who leaves office in January, has made few public statements about the accelerating pace of executions but has previously said his aim is to deliver justice to victims’ families who have waited decades. “I felt I owed it to them to make sure this ran very smoothly. If I honestly thought someone was innocent, I would not pull the trigger,” DeSantis said last year. Another Florida death row inmate, James Dailey, 80, also remains alive despite DeSantis signing his death warrant in 2019. A federal judge halted that execution while attorneys challenged his conviction; though the stay was later lifted, DeSantis did not issue a new warrant. Florida suspended all executions during the COVID-19 pandemic before resuming them in 2023.
Robertson’s case has become a focal point for death penalty opponents, who argue it illustrates a fundamental contradiction in capital punishment policy. Maria DeLiberato, legal and policy director of Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, issued a statement calling for broader reflection. “Frank Hart deserved to be safe in state custody, and his loved ones deserve our compassion,” DeLiberato said. “When someone commits murder to try to secure his own execution, we have to confront the conditions that contributed to that decision and the reality that the existence of the death penalty may have caused the very violence it purportedly prevents.” Supporters of capital punishment have long argued that the death penalty functions as a societal deterrent. Robertson’s case, in which a prisoner deliberately committed murder to obtain a death sentence, has given opponents a pointed rebuttal to that claim. Robertson’s execution also comes amid heightened national scrutiny of execution procedures. Two weeks ago, Tennessee death row inmate Christa Pike survived an execution attempt after reportedly receiving two lethal doses of pentobarbital. The Pentagon also announced last week that the firing squad execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Malik Hasan would be livestreamed. All Florida executions are carried out using a three-drug lethal injection protocol consisting of a sedative, a paralytic agent and a drug intended to stop the heart, according to the state Department of Corrections.
Robertson’s execution is scheduled for noon Tuesday at Florida State Prison near Starke. If it proceeds as planned, Florida will have carried out 17 executions in 2026, with two more — William Reaves on Oct. 20 and Jesse Guardado on Nov. 5 — still on the calendar before year’s end.

