BOSTON, MA — A former Massachusetts police officer went on trial Friday in federal court, accused of strangling his pregnant former girlfriend in her Canton apartment in 2021 and staging the scene to look like a suicide after years of alleged sexual exploitation dating back to when she was a teenager.
Matthew Farwell, 40, a former detective with the Stoughton Police Department, faces two federal charges: killing a witness or victim and causing the death of an unborn child. His victim, Sandra Birchmore, was 23 years old and between eight and ten weeks pregnant when she was found dead on February 4, 2021. Local and state authorities initially ruled her death a suicide, and no criminal charges were filed for more than three years. The FBI stepped in, leading to Farwell’s arrest in August 2024. If convicted, he faces a mandatory sentence of life in prison. The trial, presided over by Chief U.S. District Judge Denise Casper at the John J. Moakley Courthouse in Boston, is expected to last about five weeks.
Prosecutors and defense attorneys delivered sharply opposing accounts of Birchmore’s final hours during opening statements Friday morning. A jury of 10 men and six women — including four alternates — was seated after three days of selection that drew more than 400 prospective jurors. Assistant U.S. Attorney Torey B. Cummings told jurors that Farwell was supposed to be a mentor to Birchmore but instead used his position to exploit her. “She could end his life with the information she had, so he decided to end hers first,” Cummings said. The prosecutor said Farwell texted Birchmore on the evening of February 1, 2021, asking if he could come over. Surveillance video, which Cummings played for jurors, showed a hooded, masked man — whom prosecutors identify as Farwell — entering Birchmore’s Canton apartment building and leaving about 30 minutes later. Birchmore’s final outgoing message that night was a text telling Farwell she would leave the door unlocked.
Cummings outlined a relationship spanning roughly eight years, built on secrecy and control. Birchmore joined the Stoughton Police Department’s Explorers program in 2010, when she was 12 years old. Her mother, who faced chronic health problems, enrolled her hoping she would find structure and positive role models. Farwell had participated in the same program as a youth and later signed on as a volunteer instructor after joining the department. By late 2012, when Birchmore was 15 and Farwell was 27, he had sent her a Facebook friend request and began tutoring her at a local library, according to prosecutors. The sexual relationship allegedly began in April 2013 — roughly one month before Farwell married his wife. Investigators discovered more than 40,000 messages between Farwell and Birchmore on her electronic devices. Cummings told jurors that Farwell instructed Birchmore to delete their texts and met her for sex on occasion while he was on duty. In the fall of 2020, Birchmore learned through a friend — identified in court as Abington police Officer Josh Heal — that Farwell was expecting his third child with his wife, and she issued him an ultimatum: get her pregnant, or she would expose their relationship.
Prosecutors say Farwell agreed to Birchmore’s demands in order to keep her quiet, having unprotected sex with her in October, November, and December 2020. When Birchmore told him in late December that she was pregnant, he grew cold but did not deny paternity, according to Cummings. Both believed he was the father; DNA testing conducted later excluded him. Birchmore was excited about the pregnancy, sending Farwell updates about her due date, ultrasounds, doctor appointments, and a planned gender reveal. She had prepared a social media announcement and planned to go public on Valentine’s Day, two weeks after her death. In January 2021, a friend of Birchmore’s called Stoughton police and reported the relationship to a dispatcher, which prosecutors say enraged Farwell. Text messages he sent around that time read, “What else do I have to worry about now,” according to Cummings. The prosecutor also told jurors that Farwell’s wife was scheduled to give birth the morning of February 2, 2021 — the day after Birchmore died — and that an approaching blizzard created the possibility that Birchmore’s body might not be found for several days. The prosecution alleges Farwell used a duffel bag strap to strangle Birchmore and then staged the apartment to mimic a suicide. Prosecutors said his DNA was found on the strap around her neck, and that a clasp on the strap left an imprint on her chest consistent with the hardware’s measurements, according to medical expert Dr. William Smock, who also testified in the 2021 Derek Chauvin trial. Smock reviewed the autopsy and concluded that Birchmore’s hyoid bone — a small neck bone — was fractured, an injury more commonly associated with strangulation than with suicide by hanging.
Defense attorney Kimberly Stevens offered a different account, telling jurors that Farwell went to Birchmore’s apartment that night to end their relationship, not to kill her. “Matthew Farwell is a man who had an affair,” Stevens said during her opening statement, standing next to Farwell with her arm on his shoulder. “He did not kill Sandra Birchmore. He did not.” Stevens said Farwell told Birchmore that night: “That’s not my baby. The timeline doesn’t work.” She argued that Birchmore, isolated and in financial distress with less than three dollars in her bank account, killed herself in what Stevens called “an impulsive act of despair.” Stevens pointed to internet activity on Birchmore’s phone the day she died, including searches and images referencing suicide, one of which read, “Can I die just for a day? I just want to see who would cry.” The defense also noted that Birchmore had spent Thanksgiving and Christmas alone, had experienced pregnancy complications requiring a hospital visit, and had a prior history of suicidal ideation — which Stevens described as a significant risk factor. On forensic evidence, Stevens told jurors that Farwell’s DNA was not found under Birchmore’s fingernails, arguing that someone being strangled would typically scratch and claw at an attacker. She also cast doubt on DNA mixture evidence, saying that Farwell’s presence could not be conclusively established from mixed samples found on the ligature. Stevens noted the initial autopsy, conducted by Dr. Maria Capo Martinez, ruled the death a suicide, and that FBI meeting notes from early in the federal investigation initially stated there was “no evidence to contradict the medical examiner’s conclusion of suicide.”
The case drew fresh attention to a pattern of alleged institutional failure. Birchmore’s death was originally investigated by the Norfolk County State Police Detective Unit — the same unit that later came under heavy scrutiny for its handling of the 2022 death of Boston police officer John O’Keefe. Cummings told jurors that state troopers assigned to the case “did very little to actually investigate” and “very quickly told others this was definitively a suicide,” which she said led the medical examiner to reach the same conclusion without full knowledge of Birchmore’s relationship with Farwell. Norfolk County District Attorney Michael Morrissey declined to prosecute after state investigators deemed the death a suicide, and for years Birchmore’s family and supporters publicly called for “Justice for Sandra” without result. The medical examiner’s office formally withdrew its suicide ruling in April and reclassified the manner of death as “undetermined” after federal experts concluded her injuries were inconsistent with self-inflicted hanging. Farwell has been decertified as a police officer and is barred from working in Massachusetts law enforcement. He has been held without bail at a Rhode Island detention facility since his August 2024 arrest. Court documents note that Farwell’s twin brother, William Farwell, and Explorers program director Robert Devine were also accused by Birchmore’s family of sexually abusing her over the years; all three resigned in 2022 as investigations opened, but only Matthew Farwell faces criminal charges. A wrongful death lawsuit filed by Birchmore’s aunt remains on hold pending the outcome of the criminal trial, and William Farwell is listed among 68 prosecution witnesses.
Outside the Moakley Courthouse after opening statements, Jean Falletti, a former neighbor of Birchmore’s who said her son was friends with the victim, pushed back firmly against the suicide theory. “She was a sweetheart. She was a doll,” Falletti said. “She was very happy to be a mom. That was like the best thing she could ever have asked for.” Just days before Birchmore’s death, Falletti said, Birchmore had stopped by to show her car seats, onesies, and baby items. “This suicide thing is just what they have to use,” Falletti said of the defense’s argument. “She wasn’t in that mindset at all.” Sandra’s cousin Barbara Wright, who sat in the front row during opening statements alongside five other family members, said she hoped the truth would emerge at trial. “My hope is that they’ll see the truth and the truth will come out,” Wright said. WBZ legal analyst Jennifer Roman said the prosecution faces a specific legal test, noting it must prove not only that Farwell killed Birchmore intentionally, but that he did so to prevent her from reporting a federal crime to law enforcement — a threshold the defense also targeted, arguing that Birchmore’s threats were directed at Farwell’s wife, not federal authorities.
Jurors were excused shortly before noon Friday following opening statements and will return Tuesday morning after the Columbus Day holiday. The first six prosecution witnesses are expected to include Stoughton Police Detective Heather Cheever, who served as Birchmore’s mentor in the Explorers program; Cheryl Carlson, an assistant principal at the Sharon elementary school where Birchmore worked as a teacher’s aide; two employees of Birchmore’s Canton apartment building; Canton Police Officer Ensley Cotard; and Massachusetts State Police Trooper Matthew Dunne, both of whom were among the first officers to find Birchmore’s body. Judge Casper said she anticipates testimony will run approximately five weeks.

