NORTH COLLEGE HILL, OH — An Ohio mother who teaches youth Bible classes at her church was released without bail Monday after prosecutors accused her of threatening a teenage girl on the street and then directing her own 17-year-old daughter to physically attack the same teen, with the confrontation allegedly captured on surveillance video.
November Alisha Brooks, 38, of North College Hill, appeared in Hamilton County court on Monday, Oct. 5, and was released on her own recognizance. She faces four misdemeanor charges: assault, inciting to violence, menacing, and disorderly conduct. The charges stem from a Friday morning incident on Bising Avenue in which prosecutors say Brooks first threatened a juvenile classmate of her daughter’s who was walking to school, then drove alongside the girl and ordered her daughter to get out of the car and beat her. The case has drawn attention because of the unusual spectacle of an adult allegedly orchestrating a physical attack between teenagers — and because, according to her attorney, Brooks is a community fixture who teaches children at her church.
According to court documents obtained by local Fox affiliate WXIX, the encounter unfolded in the 1800 block of Bising Avenue on a Friday morning. Brooks allegedly spotted the teenage girl walking to school, made verbal threats toward her, and then got into her vehicle with her 17-year-old daughter. She allegedly drove up alongside the same girl, stopped the car, and told her daughter to get out and assault the classmate. Hamilton County Prosecutor Mike Keeling told the court that the entire sequence of events was recorded on camera and that North College Hill police officers viewed the footage before filing charges. “This incident is caught on video, and the officers have viewed that video and filed the charges,” Keeling said. Brooks’ daughter is identified in court documents but has not been charged with any crime in connection with the incident. Her defense attorney, Kevin Bobo, disputed the core allegation, telling the court that Brooks did not instruct her daughter to attack anyone.
Bobo offered a competing account of what led to the confrontation, saying a dispute had been simmering over social media. “There’s a 17-year-old who lives across the street. Something to do with social media and a boy liking somebody’s picture,” Bobo said in court. He told the judge the other teenagers had approached Brooks’ daughter the night before, that Brooks did not call police at that time, and that the following morning, while driving her daughter to school, the group crossed paths again. Bobo argued that the daughter got out of the car on her own and that his client had not been searching for the other girl. He also noted that Brooks has no prior criminal history, is employed, and has family support. “Her mother wanted the court to know she teaches a Bible class to the youth at her church,” Bobo said. It remains unclear from court records whether any physical contact actually occurred between the two teens during the incident, and that detail had not been publicly confirmed as of Monday’s hearing.
Cincinnati defense attorney Mark Krumbein, who is not connected to the case but spoke to WXIX as a legal analyst, said adult-directed juvenile assaults are rarely prosecuted. “Very unusual and seldom seen in the court system and normally very difficult to prove,” Krumbein said. However, he noted that the existence of video footage could significantly change the calculus. Krumbein also flagged an unresolved question: why Brooks’ daughter has not been charged. “If the allegations are true, you would think the child would be charged also. Unless — the child might say, ‘Well, I was just doing what mom told me to do,'” he said. The video at the center of the case was not played during Monday’s court appearance, and it may not become publicly available unless the matter goes to trial. Keeling confirmed police had reviewed the footage before bringing charges, but neither the content of the video nor its source — whether security camera, doorbell camera, or otherwise — was disclosed in open court.
The charges Brooks faces carry meaningful potential consequences despite being classified as misdemeanors under Ohio law. Simple assault under Ohio Revised Code Section 2903.13 is a first-degree misdemeanor carrying up to 180 days in jail and a $1,000 fine. Inciting to violence under Ohio Revised Code Section 2917.01 is similarly a first-degree misdemeanor when the underlying offense is itself a misdemeanor. Menacing under Ohio Revised Code Section 2903.22 is a fourth-degree misdemeanor, requiring prosecutors to prove only that Brooks knowingly caused the victim to believe she faced physical harm — not that any contact occurred. Combined, if convicted on all four counts, Brooks could face up to 13 months in jail. The case also arrives at a notable legal moment in Ohio: Gov. Mike DeWine signed House Bill 455 in July, clarifying under state law that a juvenile court delinquency adjudication is not required before prosecutors can charge an adult who allegedly aids, encourages, or induces a minor to commit a delinquent act. That change was scheduled to take effect Oct. 9, 2026 — four days after Monday’s hearing.
The incident unfolded in a neighborhood that has seen a pattern of youth-related conflict. In September 2024, gunfire on the same block of Bising Avenue forced officials to halt a high school football game at an adjacent stadium. More recently, North College Hill City Schools logged 11 student expulsion hearings related to fighting in just the first 11 school days of the 2026 academic year, prompting Superintendent Eugene Blalock to publicly call on parents to help teach conflict resolution at home. The Brooks case has, perhaps ironically, become an example of the opposite — an adult allegedly escalating a teen dispute rather than defusing it. Broader Cincinnati-area crime data shows the city recorded 283 shooting victims in 2025, a 20 percent decline from 353 the prior year, a drop officials have credited to targeted violent-crime reduction efforts. Whether the local youth-conflict trend reflects a separate dynamic from gun violence statistics remains an open question for school and city officials.
Bobo argued Monday that his client poses no danger to the community and should not be detained. The judge agreed, releasing Brooks without requiring her to post bail. Keeling did not oppose the release but made clear prosecutors stand behind the charges and the evidence supporting them. If Brooks is convicted, Krumbein noted that her background — including her church role, employment, and clean record — while irrelevant to a jury’s guilty or not-guilty verdict, could factor into a judge’s sentencing decision. “It won’t affect whether she’s found guilty or not guilty if there’s a trial, but if she is found guilty it certainly can affect the sentencing,” Krumbein said. Brooks’ daughter remains uncharged as of Monday, and no explanation has been provided by prosecutors or police as to whether juvenile charges are being considered or have been ruled out.
Brooks is due back in Hamilton County court on Nov. 10 for her next scheduled appearance. The video evidence police say they possess — and which prosecutors have called central to their case — has not been released publicly and may remain sealed unless the matter proceeds to trial. Whether Brooks’ daughter will face charges of her own, and what the footage actually shows, are the two most consequential unanswered questions heading into her next court date.

